Armchair Travel
Thursday, March 23, 2006
  The Judge Dee Mysteries
The Judge Dee mysteries by Robert Van Gulik are also all good. There's about a dozen of them. Some of them are better than others, but they're all very enjoyable.

Van Gulik was a Dutch diplomat in China and Japan for many years. A diligent scholar and a very imaginative writer with a gift for detail, Van Gulik adapts Chinese popular stories to the Western mystery genre.

The original Judge Dee stories were like "Columbo" -- you knew who the bad guys were at the beginning and the suspense was in seeing how they got found out. Van Gulik turns that around and puts the solution at the end because that's what most Western readers are used to.

He downplays the torturing of witnesses, an established practice in Chinese courts, but he keeps one other element unique to Chinese mysteries: the supernatural assistance that the magistrate may get from the deceased.

A provincial magistrate like Judge Dee is detective, prosecutor, defense attorney, judge and jury all rolled into one. His job is to get to the bottom of things. If he wants to know something he says so and people come to the tribunal and kneel down and knock their heads on the floor and say, "This insignificant person is named so and so, and respectfully reports etc. etc." Not a bad way of getting things done if you ask me.

We get wonderful glimpses of life in Imperial China: "This guy sold his daugther into slavery -- without paying the 'selling your daughter into slavery' tax, and what's more, he was undercutting the price the government was offering for Korean war slaves."

In another book, I forget which one, we learn about the practice of fighting with "loaded sleeves." Chinese robes have these long sleeves that they use as pockets. Loading a sleeve with a rock or a lead ball is a variation on the old 'pool ball in a sock' idea. It makes a very stealthy, very deadly weapon if you know how to use it.

During the Boxer Rebellion when foreigners in China were getting massacred, a group of Roman Catholic nuns, believing all was lost, held up their hands to God. The attacking mob feared they had loaded sleeves and backed off and let them go into one of the fortified compounds -- a true story attested to in the introduction.

In "The Chinese Gold Murders," the first book, Judge Dee is on his way to his first assignment as a provincial magistrate in a province on the Korean border with his family servant Hoong Liang.

They encounter these "gentlemen of the road" -- Robin Hood types -- who demand their horses. Judge Dee doffs his traveling robes and starts sword fighting with one of the brigands and it's touch and go.

Then along comes an army patrol. Judge Dee calmly identifies himself as the new magistrate and explains to the officer that he's been traveling with his assistants and they had decided to stop and stretch their muscles and have a little fencing practice. The officer buys it and the patrol goes on its way. Then Judge Dee wants to have at it again. Is that class, or what?

The two brigands, Chao Tai and Mah Joong (not the game), recognize a classy guy when they see one and refuse to fight. Later they catch up with Judge Dee and Sergeant Hoong at a local inn and say, basically, "Hey that was a good idea you had about our being your assistants," and he hires them, which turns out to be a really good move.

The nice thing for the reader is that Chao Tai and Mah Joong can circulate in the Chinese underworld and go to floating brothels in the harbor and places like that. Van Gulik was also a collector of Chinese erotica, and, for his time, he has some pretty spicy scenes from the seamy side of Imperial China.

Scenes that seem to be -- I'm just guessing here -- written by a guy who knows what he's talking about.
 
Comments:
Good to find two more fans of Judge Dee. I always enjoy Van Gulik's introductory and other explanatory material. I posted about Robert Van Gulik and Judge Dee a while back on my blog at http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/search/label/Robert%20van%20Gulik Come visit!
===================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
 
These mysteries are fantastic. Zhu Xiao Di, thanks for the heads up, as I am thrilled by the excellent comments I've already found on your behalf.
PS- It is a great blog, Peter.
 
The Judge Dee series like the Jack Aubrey series by Patrick O'Brian provides more than just a good story (good plot, characters, etc.) it provides a great deal of knowledge about the era - social organization, thinking, and day to day life.

I wish there was a full set of Van Gulik's works recorded in English. I have found some stories on tape but many seem not to have been recorded.
 
Van Gulik is basically an Anthropology expert! The information he gives about Ancient China and its customs, should have won a Nobel price! Some of the elements of Chinese civilization he gives, have not been appreciated enough yet, although he has died 50 years ago! The only mistake I found in his books so far is about the power of Arabs in Canton, which is surely an exaggeration! The real Arabs' path is meant to be the "Silk Road", not the sea trade! Arabs' ship was (and is) the camel! From the books I mostly enjoyed the "Red Pavilion",but "Chinese Lake Murders" and "Murder in Canton" are good as well! I also hope that in the rest books I am not going to read about conspiracies for the throne, it is very tiring! Could Judge Dee arrest a common knifer, for once?
 
Post a Comment



<< Home
Literary gadfly Stephen Hartshorne writes about books that he finds at flea markets and rummage sales.

My Photo
Name:
Location: Sunderland, Massachusetts, United States

Stephen Hartshorne worked in newspapers and magazines around New England for many years and served as Information Officer in the New Hampshire Senate under Senate President Vesta Roy. He worked as a material handler for nine years at the Yankee Candle Company until the company was taken over by corporate weasels. He is currently the associate editor of GoNOMAD.com, an alternative travel website, which gives him the opportunity to correspond with writers and photographers all over the world. He lives in Sunderland, Massachusetts, with his daughter Sarah, a student at Drew University, and their cat, Dwight D. Eisenmeower. This blog is dedicated to his mom, who made him bookish.

ARCHIVES
February 2006 / March 2006 / April 2006 / May 2006 / June 2006 / July 2006 / August 2006 / September 2006 / October 2006 / November 2006 / December 2006 / January 2007 / February 2007 / March 2007 / April 2007 / May 2007 / June 2007 / July 2007 / August 2007 / September 2007 / October 2007 / November 2007 / December 2007 / January 2008 / February 2008 / March 2008 / April 2008 / May 2008 / June 2008 / July 2008 / August 2008 / September 2008 / October 2008 / November 2008 / December 2008 / January 2009 / February 2009 / March 2009 / April 2009 / May 2009 / June 2009 / July 2009 / August 2009 / September 2009 / October 2009 / November 2009 / December 2009 / January 2010 / February 2010 /


MOST RECENT POSTS
Raymond Chandler
Hammett's Heir - Raymond Chandler
Robert E. Lee and Traveler
Mary Astor En Francais
Lovely Mary Astor
The Original Hard-Boiled Dick
More About That Same Issue of American Heritage
"We Brung a Little Bacon and We Brung a Little Beans"
"It Was All Over in Less Than an Hour"
The Story of Jane Honeyman


MY FAVORITE BLOGS
  • Kent St. John's Be Our Guest
  • Max Hartshorne's Readuponit
  • Mridula's Travel Tales from India
  • Paul Shoul's new Photo Blog Round World Photo
  • GoNOMAD Travel Website Great Travel Writing
  • Sony Stark's Blog "Cross That Bridge"
  • GoNOMAD's Travel Reader Blog Travel Articles
  • Sarah Hartshorne's "Erratic in Heels"
  • Posting comments can be a pain. Email me.




  • Powered by Blogger